CO129-124 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [8-9] — Page 135

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

because it will be observed that the Ordinance now under consideration contains

• under

a suspending clause (Sec. 3/

6. Little advantage will apparently be gained by going through the Sections of the Ordinance seriatim; it will be sufficient, I think, for my present purpose to give an abstract of its enactments which I think may be fairly stated as follows:

It contemplates the extinction of all Brothels in Hong Kong, excepting such as are registered in the office of the Registrar General and are within certain specified limits, and visits with severe penalties persons who shall be convicted of violating this provision.

8. It invests the Registrar General with power to declare any House a Brothel and to give notice of his having so done to the Landlord or Crown, and, in the case of the Landlord or known Lessee being desirous of disputing his decision, gives power to the Landlord or Crown Lessee to appeal to two Magistrates.

It brings within its purview and control all registered Brothels and provides for their being inspected from time to time by certain officers, including the Registrar General and Colonial Surgeon, the latter of whom is required to visit each registered Brothel and examine each of the Inmates at least once in every ten days, and in the event of any prostitute being declared by the Colonial Surgeon to be affected with Venereal Disease, it provides that she shall be removed under order of the Registrar General, there to be kept until cured at the expense of the keeper of the Brothel from whence such woman shall have been removed.

10. It makes it highly penal for a prostitute to infect any person with a Venereal Disease, and lastly introduces certain provisions with respect to Lewd women, to which, however, it is unnecessary further here to refer as they are re-enacted with certain slight modifications in the present Ordinance.

11. I proceed, in the second place, to consider the insufficiency of the Ordinance of 1857 to grapple with the great social evil which it was intended to suppress. So to its general principle, perhaps, no substantial objection can be offered, and to say that it has effected no benefit would be a departure from the truth.

12. When, however, the magnitude of the evil to be encountered is taken into consideration, the in too many cases recklessness of the parties sought to be benefited, and the difficulty of distinguishing Brothels property

Edit History

2026-05-19 20:51:41 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
because it will be observed that the Ordinance now under consideration contains under a suspending clause (Sec. 3/ 6. Little advantage will apparently be gained by going through the Sections of the Ordinance seriatim; it will be sufficient, I think, for my present purpose to give an abstract of its enactments which I think may be fairly stated as follows: It contemplates the extinction of all Brothels in Hong Kong, excepting such as are registered in the office of the Registrar General and are within certain specified limits, and visits with severe penalties persons who shall be convicted of violating this provision. 8. It invests the Registrar General with power to declare any House a Brothel and to give notice of his having so done to the Landlord or Crown, and, in the case of the Landlord or known Lessee being desirous of disputing his decision, gives power to the Landlord or Crown Lessee to appeal to two Magistrates. It brings within its purview and control all registered Brothels and provides for their being inspected from time to time by certain officers, including the Registrar General and Colonial Surgeon, the latter of whom is required to visit each registered Brothel and examine each of the Inmates at least once in every ten days, and in the event of any prostitute being declared by the Colonial Surgeon to be affected with Venereal Disease, it provides that she shall be removed under order of the Registrar General, there to be kept until cured at the expense of the keeper of the Brothel from whence such woman shall have been removed. 10. It makes it highly penal for a prostitute to infect any person with a Venereal Disease, and lastly introduces certain provisions with respect to Lewd women, to which, however, it is unnecessary further here to refer as they are re-enacted with certain slight modifications in the present Ordinance. 11. I proceed, in the second place, to consider the insufficiency of the Ordinance of 1857 to grapple with the great social evil which it was intended to suppress. So to its general principle, perhaps, no substantial objection can be offered, and to say that it has effected no benefit would be a departure from the truth. 12. When, however, the magnitude of the evil to be encountered is taken into consideration, the in too many cases recklessness of the parties sought to be benefited, and the difficulty of distinguishing Brothels property
Baseline (Original)
because it will be observed that the Ordinance now em der consideration conta under a suspending clause pSec. 3/ 6. Little advantage will apparently be gained by going through the Sections of the Ordinance Sereatim; it will be sufficient I think for my present purpose to give abstract of its enactments which I think may be fairly stated as follows: It contemplates the extinction of all Brothels in stongkong excepting such as are registered in the office of the Registra General and are within certain specified limits and visits with severe penalties, person who shall be convicted of violating this provision. 8 . It invests the Registrar General with power to declare any House a Brothel a to jive notice of his having so done to the Landlord or Crown and, in the con of the Landlord or known Lessee being desirous of disputing his decision, gives, power to the Landlord or Crown Lefsee to appeal to two Magistrates. Dani It brings within its purview and conti all registered Brothels and provides for being inspected from time to tim by certam afficers including the Regietis General and Colonical Surgeon, the latte of whom is required to irsiteach registers o 128 Brothel and examine each off the Inmates at least once in every ten days, and in the event of any prostitute being declared by the Colonial Surgeon to be affected with Venereal Diseage it provides that she Will shall be removed under order of the Registrar General, there to be kept until cured at the expense of the sleeper of the Brothel from a whence such woman shall have been removed. 10. It makes it highly penal for a prostitute to infect any person with a tenereal Disease and lastly lastly introduces certam provisions with respect to Leamen to which however it is unnecessary further here to refer as they are reenacted with certain slight modifications. in the present Ordinance. 11. Iproceed in the second place to consider: the insufficiency of the Ordinance of 1857 to 5 grapple with the great social evil which it was intended to suppress. So it's general principle perhaps oro substantial objection. can be offered and to say that it hav effected no benefit would be a departure from the truth. 12. When however the magnitude of the evil to be encountered is taken into consi- -deration, the in too on many cases recklessness of the parties sought to be benefited, and the difficulty of distinguishing Brothels property محمد
2026-05-19 20:51:41 · Baseline
View content

because it will be observed that the Ordinance now em der consideration conta

• under

a suspending clause pSec. 3/

6. Little advantage will apparently be gained by going through the Sections of the Ordinance Sereatim; it will be sufficient I think for my present purpose to give abstract of its enactments which I think may be fairly stated as

follows:

It contemplates the extinction of all Brothels in stongkong excepting such as are registered in the office of the Registra General and are within certain specified limits and visits with severe penalties, person who shall be convicted of violating this provision.

8 . It invests the Registrar General with power to declare any House a Brothel a to jive notice of his having so done to the

Landlord or Crown

and, in the con

of the Landlord or known Lessee being desirous of disputing his decision, gives, power to the Landlord or Crown Lefsee to appeal to two Magistrates.

Dani

It brings within its purview and conti all registered Brothels and provides for being inspected from time to tim by certam afficers including the Regietis General and Colonical Surgeon, the latte of whom is required to irsiteach registers

o

128

Brothel and examine each off the Inmates at least once in every ten days, and in the event of any prostitute being declared by the Colonial Surgeon to be affected with Venereal Diseage it provides that she Will shall be removed under order of the Registrar General, there to be kept until cured at the expense of the sleeper of the Brothel from

a

whence such woman shall have been removed.

10. It makes it highly penal for a prostitute to infect any person with a tenereal Disease and lastly

lastly introduces certam provisions with respect to Leamen to which however it is unnecessary further here to refer as they are reenacted with certain slight modifications. in the present Ordinance.

11. Iproceed in the second place to consider: the insufficiency of the Ordinance of 1857

to

5 grapple with the great social evil which it was intended to suppress. So it's general principle perhaps oro substantial objection. can be offered and to say that it hav effected no benefit would be a departure from the truth.

12. When however the magnitude of the

evil to be encountered is taken into consi- -deration, the in too on

many cases recklessness of the parties sought to be benefited, and the difficulty of distinguishing Brothels property

محمد

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.